Insider Tips
Written by serving officers who have sat on both sides of the promotion board. These are the things candidates get wrong, the things that make assessors sit up, and the things nobody tells you until it is too late.
16 tips across four areas — answers, mindset, preparation, and the bigger picture.
The single biggest mistake
CRITICALYour AnswersEvery candidate loses marks to the same error. They say we.
Numbers are not optional
CRITICALYour AnswersPerformance improved significantly is an opinion. Specific numbers are evidence.
You do not need a dramatic story
CRITICALBefore Your BoardPanels recognise when a candidate has chosen the biggest story rather than the best one.
Know how long you actually speak for
CRITICALIn the RoomMost candidates have no idea. Your target is five to six minutes.
The panel will push back. Hold your ground.
CRITICALIn the RoomSome panels deliberately challenge your answers to test your resolve.
Your language must already sound like the rank you are going for
CRITICALYour AnswersBoards are asking one question: can this person do the job we are promoting them into?
Show what changed, not just what you did
CRITICALYour AnswersWeak answers describe actions. Strong answers describe impact.
One example can answer six different questions
Before Your BoardKnow your examples so thoroughly you can present any one through whichever CVF lens the question demands.
Silence before you answer reads as confidence
In the RoomTaking five to ten seconds before you begin signals composure, not uncertainty.
Use the NDM and say you are using it
The Bigger PictureThe National Decision Model signals structured professional thinking.
Name the CVF competency, but make it sound natural
Your AnswersDo not leave the panel guessing which competency your answer is addressing.
End every answer with a values connection
Your AnswersCompetencies are assessed. Values are what panels look for in leaders.
Know your force's inspection picture
The Bigger PictureAt Inspector and above, boards expect awareness of the wider policing context.
Read the room and adapt
In the RoomReading the room and adapting your delivery is itself a live demonstration of emotional awareness.
Ask for feedback whatever the outcome
Before Your BoardA debrief after a failed board is one of the most valuable pieces of development you will ever receive.
You do not need a blockbuster example
Before Your BoardDo not reach for the biggest story. Reach for the clearest one.
Read the full tips inside State6
The full tips include the complete breakdown — why each mistake happens, specific language to use, and how to fix it in your answers. Track which tips you have reviewed, filter by category, and search by keyword.
Get started with State6 →